Friday, January 11, 2008

The New York Times



January 10, 2008
Books of The Times

Tom Cruise and His Bully Pulpit


By JANET MASLIN

TOM CRUISE
An Unauthorized Biography
By Andrew Morton
Illustrated. 344 pages. St. Martin’s Press. $25.95.

If Andrew Morton’s “Tom Cruise: An Unauthorized Biography” is published peacefully next Tuesday, one of its basic assertions will be undermined. That is because if Mr. Morton is right about the litigious fervor of either Mr. Cruise, who is the book’s ostensible subject, or the Church of Scientology, which is its real one, the publication will be met with dirty tricks, messianic anger and relentless harassment. If Mr. Morton is wrong about that, there will be fewer fireworks. After all, among this biography’s revelations is the fact that Tom Cruise was a cute kid.

Mr. Morton, “a leading authority on modern celebrity” (according to this book’s jacket copy) and the mouthpiece for 1992 payback to the royal family by Diana, Princess of Wales (“Diana: Her True Story”), is best equipped for one thing: treating the travails of the famous as matters of earth-shaking consequence. He has gravitated to subjects who either appreciate (Monica Lewinsky) or wield (Madonna) some form of intoxicating power.

In the case of Mr. Cruise, Mr. Morton sees a domineering, aggressive character who has joined forces with Scientology to catapult his activities beyond the realm of mere glitter. “More than any star today,” Mr. Morton writes, “Tom” — naturally he’s on a first-name basis — “is a movie messiah who reflects and refracts the fears and doubts of our times, trading on the unfettered power of modern celebrity, our embrace of religious extremism and the unnerving scale of globalization.” The book asserts that “the relentless expansion of the organization and its front groups has been made possible by the charm and persuasiveness of its poster boy, whose modernity, familiarity and friendliness mask the totalitarian zeal of his faith.”

It goes without saying that biographers do not ordinarily assail their subjects’ religious beliefs with impunity. Nor do investigative reporters seize on Scientology as frequently as they might. Yet Mr. Morton has found a number of former Scientologists who are willing to speak freely, and in some cases vengefully, about the group’s purported inner workings. Mr. Morton’s eagerness to include their voices leads him to push the limits of responsible reporting. In the absence of any hard information whatsoever, for instance, he notes that if Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes, now his wife, fed their daughter Suri the barley-based baby formula recommended by L. Ron Hubbard, Scientology’s founder, “they kept it secret.” And that despite Mr. Cruise’s legal victories over publications that have described him as gay, that assertion lives on in the form of widespread Internet rumors.

The Tom Cruise of this book is emphatically, unremarkably heterosexual throughout its tedious opening chapters about his boyhood. “I was black and blue from the gearshift, I can tell you that,” says a high school girlfriend who spent time with him in a car. Mr. Cruise is also said to have collected model airplanes, impersonated Woody Woodpecker and done a standout job of playing the Sun in a fifth-grade pageant. “Even 30 years later it still gives me goose bumps,” one of his schoolteachers recalls about the budding star’s performance.

“The film will never sell and Tom Cruise will not be an important actor,” a Fox executive once memorably said. Still, the book describes Mr. Cruise’s speedy rise from walk-on obscurity (“Endless Love” in 1981) to the Hollywood stratosphere (“Top Gun” in 1986 ) while placing more emphasis on the evolution of his private life. By 1985 he had become involved with Mimi Rogers, his first wife, who provided entrĂ©e into the world of Scientology. Even though Scientology abhors psychiatry, Mr. Morton plays doctor by speculating that Mr. Cruise made an especially receptive recruit because he is “an uncertain child waiting for an undeserved blow from his father.”

Although Mr. Morton is readily assailable for making such facile remarks, he is in some larger sense an astute observer. His overall impression of Mr. Cruise makes sense. He provides a credible portrait extrapolated from the actor’s on-the-record remarks and highly visible public behavior. This book describes a controlling, fervent figure (“He was like a walking light bulb,” recalls one observer) whose personal needs dovetailed with the strict hierarchical structure of his newfound faith and who, at some point, decided to dedicate himself wholeheartedly to proselytizing spiritually, emotionally and politically on its behalf. The book surmises that it was a small leap from this outlook to jumping up and down on Oprah Winfrey’s sofa.

Among the pivotal players in this slow-starting but eventually scalding book are Stanley Kubrick, whose manipulative treatment of Mr. Cruise and his second wife, Nicole Kidman, during the marathon filming of “Eyes Wide Shut” is made to seem especially damaging here; Ms. Kidman herself, though her troubles with Mr. Cruise have been dissected by other biographers; and David Miscavige, the Church of Scientology’s powerful leader. Mr. Miscavige is presented as someone whose outlook and gestures Mr. Cruise has visibly appropriated and who himself shares Mr. Cruise’s gung-ho proclivities.

It is the nature of this book to depict Mr. Miscavige also as a kind of mustache-twirling villain, complete with the requisite B-movie dialogue. After Mr. Cruise agreed to visit the church’s heavily guarded Gold Base compound in the California desert in the summer of 1989, the book says, Mr. Miscavige “gleefully announced to his closest staff, ‘the most important recruit ever is in the process of being secured. His arrival will change the face of Scientology forever.’ ” Mr. Morton would be on much more solid ground had he backed that quotation with direct or even second-hand attribution.

If “Tom Cruise: The Unauthorized Biography” attracts as much flak as it does interest, the fuss will be less about blind quotations than about interpretation. The terminology and precepts of Scientology (“Teegeeack,” “Xenu,” “MEST”) can be treated as exceedingly weird. And at times the book seems to go out of its way to misunderstand them. The phrase “merchant of chaos” has been used by Mr. Cruise to excoriate his father, and Mr. Morton treats it as a sinister epithet. Maybe it is. But it is also used by the literature of Scientology to describe those who profit by promulgating disturbing thoughts. Authorities on celebrity are not immune to this accusation.

Wednesday, January 09, 2008

First glance at the dreaded "Bush Book"

Will Tarnished Heisman bring down Reggie Bush and USC? I just picked up my mail and found a review copy of the new book on Reggie Bush.

It doesn't look good.

The jacket cover claims point-blank, "With the explosive information revealed in Tarnished Heisman, Bush stands to be ruled ineligible -- a decision that could cost his alma mater the 2004 national championship title, force the forfeit of every game Bush played in after losing his eligibility, and potentially strip Reggie Bush of the shining prize of his college career: the Heisman Trophy."

Of course, that's to hype the book and create sales. Notice the phrasing "stands to." What does that really mean? We know the NCAA investigation has been underway for awhile. Now we get to see some of the evidence that they're weighing.

I get the impression that there's limited original research in Tarnished Heisman. I've just started reading, so I could be wrong on that part. My quick-glance found that the author never got a response from Bush, his family, USC, and the NCAA. A lot is based on an accumulation of third-party research (all from reliable sources like newspapers). Then there are the people like Lloyd Lake, who is currently suing Bush. He was cooperative but had to be compensated for tape recordings that he provided.

Back on the negative side for USC fans, the book's accounting says $47,000 went directly to Bush out of the overall $291,000 that went to his family. That makes it hard to deny he knew what was going on. While the photo section lacks any photocopied receipts, bank statements, or otherwise, the Author's Note says that a website will publish much of it. As of this blog post the site (www.tarnishedheisman.com) has not gone live. According to a "WhoIs" search, it's reserved under the name of a company run by the book's author, Don Yaeger. It's going to be tough to doubt the validity of something from Yaeger (a former associate editor and an investigative reporter for Sports Illustrated) and publisher Pocket Books (a division of Simon & Schuster). Expect the hard-evidence's release to coincide with the book's on January 15.

Adding to the situation's shady factor are a pair of references to characters guaranteed to make the Trojan nation uneasy ... memorabilia dealers and Suge Knight.

Bush has gotten himself out of some tough spots in the past, but this is a whole new ballgame. Instead of quietly refuting things and replicating his on-field elusiveness, maybe he could pull a Roger Clemens.

The New York Times

January 9, 2008
Television Review | 'Pioneers of Television'

When Talk Show Hosts Worked Without a Net

Wednesday night’s episode of the PBS mini-series “Pioneers of Television,” devoted to the roots of the late-night talk show, has one sequence that could be particularly helpful, or perhaps just frustrating, for current hosts who are without the services of their writing staffs.

After showing clips of some of Steve Allen’s brilliant gags on “Tonight” and its local precursor from the 1950s — the bits that David Letterman copied wholesale in the early days of “Late Night” and that would be perfectly at home on any number of shows today — the documentary informs us, “With just a single-page outline, a piano and a quick-witted personality, Allen and a few friends would create nearly two hours of entertainment every night.”

That’s twice the length of any of today’s late-night shows, done from a one-page outline that presumably wouldn’t break anyone’s strike rules. Andy Williams offers his take on how Allen, who died in 2000, was able to do it: “He didn’t speak much at all during the day.” Words to live by.

The presence of Mr. Williams illustrates one of the virtues of “Pioneers of Television,” which began last week with a look at early sitcoms and continues on the next two Wednesdays with installments on variety and game shows. Nearly all of the talking heads qualify as pioneers themselves, with an age range from 60s to dead: Mary Tyler Moore, Andy Griffith, Art Linkletter, Dick Van Dyke, Pat Harrington, Phyllis Diller, Merv Griffin. On Wednesday night a few younger figures like Jay Leno and Arsenio Hall creep in, but so far we’ve been spared the indignity of hearing Spike Feresten’s opinion of Jack Paar or Charlie Sheen’s thoughts on “The Honeymooners.”

The programs are admirably focused, with a decent amount of information about a few pivotal figures. Wednesday night’s episode covers Allen, Paar and Johnny Carson, the formative hosts of what would become “The Tonight Show,” with only sidelong glances at their rivals and successors; last week looked at five early sitcoms, from “I Love Lucy” to “The Dick Van Dyke Show.” (Fans of “Leave It to Beaver” or “Mr. Ed” were out of luck.)

The downside — and it’s a big one — is the reverence, approaching sanctification, in which the series wraps its subjects. This goes hand in hand with the hushed banality of the narration: “Under Carson, late-night television became a fixture of American life, the hearth we gather around at the end of the day,” and: “It’s a format that remains solid to this day. An art form sculpted by a small group of talented performers in a class by themselves.”

It’s a lot to sit through, but if you’re at all interested in the subject, the clips are sufficient reward: an alarmingly young Carson on “Carson’s Cellar,” a local show in Los Angeles that looks like “Wayne’s World” 40 years before its time, or a scene from “Head of the Family,” Carl Reiner’s pilot for what became “The Dick Van Dyke Show,” which starred Mr. Reiner as a not-very-funny Rob Petrie.

One of the funniest is the “Steve Allen Sundae,” with Allen, clad only in shorts and glasses, puffing on a cigar while being slathered with ice cream and yelling, “Wait a minute, these bananas are freezing.” It sure beats spinning your wedding ring on your desk.

PIONEERS OF TELEVISION

On most PBS stations on Wednesday nights at 8 through Jan. 23 (check local listings).

Directed and produced by Steve Boettcher; Mike Trinklein and Jack Jones Jr., writers. Produced by Boettcher/Trinklein Media Inc.

MSN Tracking Image
MSNBC.com

Colbert, Stewart make do without writers
But it's apparent some writing, or at least planning, of bits going on

Image: Stephen Colbert
COMMENTARY
By Andy Dehnart
MSNBC contributor
Jan. 9, 2008

The first night of Jon Stewart's return as host of "The Daily Show" — or "A Daily Show," as he said it's being called for the duration of the writers' strike — was not promising.

Stewart did not kill time, but he also seemed to be treading water as he moved from segment to segment. Most of those segments were focused on the writers' strike, and Stewart made fun of both the studios and the Writers Guild of America as he explored various aspects of their conflict. That focus lacked the show's usual life and spark, and the writers' absence, it seemed, had a deep impact.

The second night, however, didn't seem any different than a regular, albeit unremarkable, episode. Proving he was back to form, Stewart even self-deprecatingly mocked his own performance Monday. "Last night's show was through the roof, and tonight, for those of you that really enjoyed that, I have a special surprise. Tonight's show, we're going to focus purely on intellectual property and tort law," he said.

That was followed by a transition to "elections, baby," as Stewart said, and he slipped quickly and comfortably back into doing what he does best, excoriating politicians by using different video clips of them to illustrate their own hypocrisy and stupidity. Later, during the interview segment, Stewart sparred with former Bush speechwriter David Frum with his trademark lighthearted aggressiveness.

None of the somber tone of Monday's show was present, and only occasional references to the strike and the lack of writers made the episode seem different from a pre-strike one. "We miss our writers terribly, and we hope they get back here soon," Stewart said, sounding entirely genuine. At another point, he joked, "Here's the problem: Without the writers, any movie reference that I make is going to be from the '80s."

From night to night, there was a dramatic transition, and while "The Daily Show" seemed to struggle without writers upon its initial return, the second episode suggested it might not really need them, or at least will be able to survive until they return.

The only thing really missing from "The Daily Show" were the segments with its flock of correspondents, leaving Stewart with no one to play off. As if on cue, John Oliver showed up during Tuesday's second segment, allegedly reporting from "The Daily Show"'s own picketers. (Among those walking the line was the correspondent himself as the series mocked its own use of green screens yet again).

What was most interesting was how Oliver introduced his segment.

"Before we begin, let me make one thing perfectly clear," Oliver told Stewart. "I am just talking to you. This is not writing. I have absolutely no idea how the sentence I am currently saying is going to finish. When and if it does, I can only hope it makes some kind of ceramic pineapple."

A funny line, but clearly one that someone had to write, or at least plan out. Like that sentence, a lot of material had to have been written by someone or some people who did a decent, if not spectacular, job. On Monday's "Daily Show," one of the on-screen graphics continuously said, "Space Reserved for Clever Pun." So who wrote that clever line?

The same was true on "The Colbert Report." While Stephen Colbert showed off his empty teleprompters on Monday, he read from one during at least part of his Tuesday night show, joking about that but also actually reading words off a teleprompter. He pretended to find a pre-strike script ("This is a legal script!"), and then delivered material while an on-screen graphic explained, "script completed Oct. 29, 2007."

Whether or not that was true, what's clear is that both Colbert and Stewart aren't going to wait out the strike killing time, ad-libbing, or interviewing guests alone.

Considering that both shows are typically drenched in irony and satire, often making points by embracing absurd positions, perhaps their insistence that they are not being written is a tacit admission that someone's writing some things.

Stewart certainly didn't hide his irritation Monday that the Writers Guild wouldn't negotiate a deal with his series, which was unionized just two years ago. (Reports say that's because his show is not owned by an individual production company, like David Letterman's, but Viacom-owned Comedy Central — although the WGA did unionize "The Daily Show" independently.)

If their shows aren't being written in the same way as they were pre-strike, with a group of people brainstorming ideas and polishing material, they are being planned and, on some level, written. Had the writers been working this week, both shows would have probably been different, but however the shows came together on Tuesday, it actually worked.

Adequate writing and extremely smooth execution may combine to make both shows watchable, but what remains to be seen is whether that's enough to give us the satirical analysis and biting wit that we desperately need during the next 11 months.

washingtonpost.com
Hey, Isn't That . . .
People Are Doing Double-Takes, And Taking Action, As Web Snapshots Are Nabbed for Commercial Uses
Tracey Gaughran-Perez says a photo of her pug, Truman, was taken without permission and used during an NFL broadcast on Fox.
Tracey Gaughran-Perez says a photo of her pug, Truman, was taken without permission and used during an NFL broadcast on Fox. (www.sweetney.com)

By Monica Hesse
Washington Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, January 9, 2008; C01

The pug in the corner of the Saints-Eagles football telecast on Fox looked familiar to Tracey Gaughran-Perez.

Not in the slobber-smile way that all pugs look familiar, but in the who else but me would dress their pug up in a bleeping Santa suit kind of familiar.

Gaughran-Perez logged on to http://www.sweetney.com, the personal blog where she'd uploaded a snapshot of her dog, then waited for the Fox pug -- a sort of "Merry Christmas" icon -- to appear again on TV.

Argh.

The pug was definitely Truman; the photo was definitely one she'd marked as "all rights reserved."

"It's not like the picture was some golden chalice of Internet wonder. It's a picture of a stupid dog," says the Baltimore mom. "But it's my dog and it's my photo!"

Supreme irony: "Every commercial break there would be a warning from Fox saying, 'This telecast may not be reproduced,' " she says. "I guess copyright pertains only to them."

Under the banner of "intellectual property," record labels warn you not to bootleg their songs. Hollywood studios warn you not to download their movies. Intellectual property has lately seemed the concern of corporations trying to protect the artist from the grabby public.

But in an increasingly user-generated world where the public is the artist, sometimes it's the big boys who get grabby. And the questions that arise are about ownership, but they are also about fairness, and changing culture, and ultimately, the search for authenticity.

* * *

The (literal) poster child for corporate photonapping: Dallas 15-year-old Alison Chang, who paused in the middle of a church-sponsored carwash last summer to flash a goofy grin and a peace sign to her friend Justin Ho-Wee Wong. Click! Wong posted his pictures from the event on the photo-sharing Web site Flickr. A couple months later, the one of Alison resurfaced -- as part of a national ad campaign for Virgin Mobile in Australia. "Dump Your Pen Friend," the billboards read. "Free text virgin to virgin." Alison was the chump to dump.

The Chang family lawyered up.

While Wong had agreed to make his snapshots available through Creative Commons, a nonprofit that licenses photos for Flickr, he didn't anticipate commercial use, says Ryan Zehl, the attorney and spokesman for both the Chang family and Wong. Additionally, Zehl says, the license had required Wong to be attributed by name, which he was not. He and Alison, now 16, learned what had happened only when another Flickr user forwarded Wong a picture of the ad.

They're all suing Virgin Mobile Australia -- the Changs claiming Alison's violation of privacy and Wong claiming the company's failure to credit him properly.

Understanding cases such as the Changs' requires a crash course in copyright law:

Photographers (even amateur ones) automatically own the rights to their own work (even online). That means others can't use a photo without permission.

But sometimes, through "fair use," it actually is okay to use a photo without permission. Fair use can include scholarship or parody, and is determined by a number of criteria.

Further: sometimes, individuals such as Wong can decide to give away just part of their control. For example, permitting use of a photograph as long as the source is credited.

It's all doubly muddled online, where images can be thoughtlessly taken with one mouse click, such as when thousands of boys made screensavers out of high school track star Allison Stokke's photo and never once asked, "Legal?"

Clearly, the only way to really make sure your photos on the Internet don't get splashed around is not to put them up there to begin with.

In some ways the more interesting question for this corporate breed of photonapping isn't "Is it legal?" but rather, "Why does it sting so badly?"

For Niall Kennedy, the issue was hypocrisy -- the casual smugness with which corporations seemed to say, Copyright? What copyright? Kennedy had snapped photographs at a technology convention in late 2005 only to see one suddenly appear, without proper crediting, on a Microsoft-run blog.

"I've had audits where Microsoft has sent people to verify that I have copyrights for the software running on each employer's computer," says Kennedy, who once worked for Microsoft and now runs a Web technology firm. "This is a company that goes after copyright violators with the assumption of guilty until proven innocent."

The original blogger later posted an online mea culpa: "I forgot to include an attribution, which I had fully intended to do, but for which I apologise [sic] to him." Microsoft did not return calls seeking further comment.

Says Lawrence Lessig, the Stanford legal scholar who created Creative Commons, when asked about the issue of corporations borrowing photos: "There's really no excuse for [these companies] except that they think it's not important to protect the rights of the amateur."

Brandon Stone, a Web designer in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., was as flattered as he was peeved when he saw his photographs of a dirty alley appear as background in a "Real Time With Bill Maher" skit on HBO.

Still, the amateur photographer didn't want to undersell himself, and solicited advice online. While still debating a course of action, he received a call from an apologetic show producer who had been forwarded Stone's advice request.

They negotiated a price of $500 for the images used, "plus a little more for pain and suffering," Stone says. "They know the business. They have to be held to a higher standard. The average Joe doesn't have a team of lawyers telling him what's legal and what's not."

The producer's explanation? An intern, a lowly intern who didn't know any better, had grabbed the screen shots for the last-minute sketch.

Low-level employees were also the forces cited when stay-at-home dad Jim Griffioen's daughter appeared on Babble, an online parenting magazine. The story, about lead paint, featured a photo from Flickr of Juniper playing in front of a paint-peeling wall.

"It implied that I expose my daughter to all kinds of evils," says Griffioen, who hadn't agreed to licensing. "I'm just glad it wasn't an article about smoking pot [in front of] your kids," the subject of another Babble story.

Griffioen, as it happens, was once an intellectual property lawyer. When he unleashed his legalese, he says, staffers removed the photo.

Griffioen accepted their untrained-employee explanation -- until, he says, he started hearing from other bloggers who said they'd been wronged by the site. One woman said a photo of hers was improperly used for the magazine's inaugural issue. When she complained, the editor blamed . . . an intern.

"That is one very active intern," says Griffioen.

Babble, for its part, immediately admits wrongdoing, but says that the cases were not nearly as widespread as Griffioen implies. "There was a period of a few weeks where it happened as a pattern," says Rufus Griscom, Babble publisher. He says that one photo assistant did not understand permissible use, but that when the problem came to light, the offending photos were immediately removed and replaced with stock photography or with images from Flickr that Babble had permission to use. The photo assistant was fired, and the magazine reviewed all of its published images to make sure it had the photo rights.

What's noteworthy in each of these cases, Lessig says, "is that bloggers, a community typically associated with piracy, are rallying in support of copyright."

He says average individuals are increasingly thinking of themselves as artists, whose work has value -- or at least deserves respect. Lessig predicts that as the average Joes have their own material appropriated, it will eventually result in better behavior from both individuals and corporations.

Or, in total anarchy?

* * *

When news broke of the Alison Chang story earlier this fall, Virgin Mobile Australia released a statement (and has subsequently declined all interview requests, including one requested for this article). In part: the campaign "was part of an approach designed to reject cliched 'advertising' imagery in favour of more genuine and spontaneous shots."

Griscom, of Babble, similarly explained the magazine's decision to use Flickr, calling the images found there "more original, less generic."

It's easy to get so caught up debating the fairness of photonapping that we miss the other question: Why would big name corporations even want our point-and-click photographs?

The answer seems to be less "Because we can" and more "Because we need to."

"Authenticity is the new consumer sensibility," says Joe Pine, a business consultant and co-author of "Authenticity: What Consumers Really Want." It is the criterion "by which people decide what to buy and who to buy it from."

It's a byproduct of the user-generated world: the trustworthiness of YouTube, the realness of Facebook. Above all else, we believe ourselves. "People don't want to buy the fake from the phony anymore," Pine says. "They want to buy the real from the genuine."

Most of Flickr looks genuine. Type in "nerdy teen" and the current first hit is not some stylized nerd with braces and suspenders and mismatched socks. What you get instead is an image more subtle -- an old yearbook photograph of a smiling brunette, glasses not quite right, hair not quite right.

The image is more "right" than the Steve Urkel an ad firm would have concocted.

And the ad firms get that. So we get videos like Burger King's "Freakout" campaign in which real people are told the Whopper has been discontinued. They do their best to replicate real.

Viewers can spot a professional pug model from across the living room.

It all gets very meta.

And none of it is comforting to the people who have had their images grabbed online.

So while these issues of authenticity and fairness and legality are all being sorted out, amateur photographers who find themselves more famous than they would like may consider taking advice from Niall Kennedy.

When his initial e-mails to the Microsoft blog asking it to remove links to his photo didn't immediately work, Kennedy replaced the image with one of a man engaging in an activity best described as "extreme mooning." Visitors to the Microsoft blog who clicked on the innocent-looking link were guided to the new photo.

Says Kennedy, "They pulled down the link within 15 minutes."