Thursday, May 01, 2008
Bill O’Reilly: ‘We Didn’t Invade Iraq’
Yesterday, Fox News host Bill O’Reilly made the incredible claim that the United States never invaded Iraq: “We didn’t invade Iraq.” He added, “It was a declaration of war, it was a declaration to enforce the first Gulf War Treaty.” Watch it:
Despite O’Reilly’s revisionist history, the United States did invade Iraq. The U.S. military forcefully entered the country in order to overthrow that nation’s leader. That’s an invasion. During a 2006 speech, President Bush discussed his administration’s “two major invasions as a part of the war on terror.”
Even O’Reilly himself has, in the past, admitted that the United States invaded Iraq:
– “I’ll submit that most folks still have no idea why the Bush administration invaded Iraq.” [1/28/08]
– “Iraq was invaded to create a friendly country between Iran and Syria, thereby pressuring those nations into a more sensible foreign policy.” [3/6/06]
O’Reilly’s “first Gulf War Treaty” claim is also questionable. During a March 15, 2004 interview, former U.N. weapons inspector Hans Blix challenged O’Reilly on this exact point:
O’REILLY: [W]e liberate Iraq — liberate Kuwait, all right, and then we have a treaty, and the treaty says U.N. weapons inspectors are allowed to do X, Y, and Z, and 17 times Saddam says — violates those. Now you can understand why the United States government might be a little teed off about that. […]
O’REILLY: But do you understand that when you have 17 violations of a treaty, a war treaty, that you basically have to take action?
BLIX: Well, you’re talking about a war treaty. It was a cease-fire. It was not a war treaty.
O’REILLY: Oh, come on. Now don’t play semantics here, sir.
BLIX: Second — all right. I’m trying to be precise. You are imprecise.
O’Reilly’s claim is almost as unbelievable as Wolfowitz’s statement earlier this week that the U.S. “occupation [of Iraq] ended in June of 2004.”
Transcript:
BALLENTINE: We are invading Iraq.
O’REILLY: No, we’re not. We didn’t invade Iraq.
BALLENTINE: Did we go through Congress to invade, to go to war?
O’REILLY: Yes, there was a vote in Congress.
BALLENTINE: It was a declaration of war.
O’REILLY: It was a declaration of war, it was a declaration to enforce the first Gulf War Treaty, which you don’t know anything about, Mr. Ballentine.
Campuses swimming in flood of infringement notices from RIAA

By Eric Bangeman April 30, 2008
Colleges and universities around the country are seeing a significant increase in the number of copyright infringement notices that they receive from the RIAA. Schools that typically get a handful of notices in a month are now seeing several times those in a single week. The RIAA says it isn't doing anything differently, but school IT administrators are not thrilled about the extra work the notices entail.
"We have seen an increase, although it pales compared to most schools," St. Cloud State IT security coordinator Darrin Printy told Ars. "Normally, we only get about a dozen per year; now we are getting about four to six notices a week."
The story is the same at larger schools, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education, which first reported the increase. At the University of Cincinnati, the number of notices has jumped to 13 in the past two weeks, instead of the usual one or two notices per month. George Washington University has received 123 notices in the past week, compared to the usual five to ten.
"We have seen a large up-tick as well," Brian Rust, who works in the Office of the CIO at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, told Ars. "I'm told it started when we received a new batch of six pre-settlement letters two weeks ago. Since then, the instance of cease and desist letters has greatly increased as well."
One result of the increase in notices is an increased workload for university IT staff. "For my coworkers, the increase is immense," University of Wisconsin-Madison University Housing network systems administrator Marc Bourgeois told Ars. "For the people at the university that communicate with copyright holders, I'd imagine the increase in workload has been somewhat daunting."
RIAA spokesperson Cara Duckworth says that the group hasn't made any changes in procedures, but does hint that the record labels are now better able to detect infringement. "We are constantly striving to improve upon our technological ability to detect theft," Duckworth told Ars.
Although the RIAA has been eying campus P2P use for some time, the group only began sending out settlement letters in February 2007. Those letters are generally addressed to the user of an IP address at a college; if the school chooses to figure out who was using the IP address at that time and forwards it to the student, he or she is eligible for a reduced infringement settlement from the RIAA.
At the one-year anniversary of its campus enforcement program, the RIAA had sent out 5,404 settlement letters (another 569 letters went out earlier this month). The first 5,003 letters led to over 2,300 students choosing to settle. Another 2,465 were sued by the group.
Back in February, RIAA president Cary Sherman told Ars that he believed the schools were responding to the issue "in a helpful way," but the sudden and unexplained increase in copyright infringement notices may be an indication that the RIAA doesn't think colleges are being as helpful as they could. The hope may be that, frustrated by the increased labor necessary to deal with the influx of notices, university IT departments will decide to come down hard on P2P users.
Some schools, like Ohio University, have already cracked down on P2P use. Others, like the University of Oregon, have responded harshly to the RIAA's lawsuits and are battling to quash the RIAA's "unduly burdensome" subpoenas.
Unfortunately for just about everyone involved, there doesn't appear to be any end in sight. Sherman has said that the RIAA will keep up its campus P2P campaign "for as long as the marketplace demand[s]." P2P usage may be flat, but it's not decreasing. In fact, the popularity of P2P app LimeWire continues to grow and traffic on BitTorrent—which is used for sharing entire albums as well as individual songs—is up.
Why are people only noticing 'American Idol's' shenanigans now?
This week’s kerfuffle over Paula Abdul’s mistaken “American Idol” comments strikes me as weird, only because there has been funny business associated with the Fox talent show for years, but until now, nobody minded.
Maybe people are making a fuss now because the television behemoth is in trouble, with its ratings declining by double digits over last season (which also saw a decline from the previous season).
On Wednesday, Abdul told Ryan Seacrest in a radio interview that she had watched Jason Castro perform in the dress rehearsals for Tuesday’s show. That’s why she got mixed up midway through the Tuesday program and critiqued both of his songs, even though he had only performed one tune when the judges were queried.
She also gave another excuse to US magazine – she said she’d gotten her notes on Castro mixed up with those for David Cook. But let’s face it, another excuse is that she’s Paula Abdul and there has to be some scandal about her behavior every season or the American public feels cheated.
The bigger question is, why are “Idol’s” shenanigans only being noticed or commented on now?
In an 2007 interview, contestant Gina Glocksen told me that the show edited one of her audition performances to make it appear as though she had sung “Black Velvet” for Randy Jackson, Abdul and Simon Cowell. Glocksen hadn’t performed that song for them, she sang it for a producer.
“There’s a lot of editing,” Glocksen said. Other auditioners have said similar things over the years, according to VoteForTheWorst.com, but nobody cared.
Some other fictions: “Idol” has always insisted that it is searching for the best singer in America, but it often showcases the worst. Are “Idol” producers hoping Juilliard-trained opera singers walk in the door during audition season? Please.
Even those performers who make it to the final 20 or so aren’t playing on a level field: Favored contestants usually get showcase spots near the end of the program. This season, "Idol" tried to gloss over Carly Smithson's major-label past until an uproar forced them to address it.
The show has demonstrated similar arrogance over this week's Paula scandal -- Ryan Seacrest didn't address the allegation that the show may be scripted in Wednesday's program, he merely said "rumors" about Paula aren't true, which is not a real answer to fans' legitimate questions.
As Orlando Sentinel critic Hal Boedeker wrote, "Instead of sharing its process, "American Idol" has carried on as if it has something to hide. It's a rather stupid way to conduct business, isn't it?"
But secrecy and image manipulation is all part of the "Idol" game. Speaking of the performers, they are usually younger than 40 – the show may give lots of airtime to mature “mentors” but how many Top 10 performers have reached the ripe old age of 30?
And those women at the foot of the stage? They are not hardcore “Idol” fanatics, they’re sorority sisters imported from UCLA. Audience members are told when to clap and when to wave their hands.
The judges are not often in their seats during the course of live shows, according to a recent New York Times piece. Performances by guest artists and Q&A bits are pre-taped.
All in all, “‘American Idol’ is as scripted as a ‘reality’ show dare be,” Edward Wyatt wrote in the Times on April 22, well before the Paula scandal.
The surprising thing is that the judges were able to feign interest this long. Certainly the Nielsen numbers indicate that viewers are losing interest. The fact that Abdul’s latest folly is getting any traction in the media and among the public is proof that the bloom is off the rose for this 6-year old franchise.
Though David Archuleta is genuinely talented, David Cook is the only performer worth paying attention to at this point. And the sad fact is, it’d be a nightmare for him if he won “Idol.” The record deal he’d be forced into would result in the blandification of a truly original performer. What does it say about “Idol” that I hope that Cook does not win it?
Fox executives have to be wondering how much longer their hugely successful show will remain the Death Star of television. How long can “Idol” force America to those endless, preposterous audition rounds followed by weeks of inept tributes to the songbooks of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Neil Diamond?
As Time's James Poniewozik wrote, "'Idol's' ratings were already dropping off, but uninteresting finalists, a stale format and overly bloated episodes are a far bigger threat to 'Idol' than yet another Paula embarrassment." I agree.
Fox is reportedly looking into changing the show’s format next season, and perhaps jettisoning the audition weeks and showing them only as flashbacks.
Can “American Idol” script a flashback to happier days, when no one even began to question its dominance? That remains to be seen.
Details Emerge in eBay v. Craigslist
The fuzzy edges around the eBay-Craigslist spat — the subject of a sealed complaint filed last week — came somewhat into focus yesterday with the release of a redacted version of the complaint.
EBay, which acquired a 28.4% stake in Craigslist back in 2004, creating an unlikely union between an Internet powerhouse and a classified listings site with a cult following, is now suing closely-held Craigslist in the Delaware Court of Chancery for diluting its stake. Last week, in a blog entry posted on its site, Craigslist said it was “surprised and very disappointed” by what it said were eBay’s “unfounded allegations.”
But, reports the WSJ, in a redacted version of the complaint made available yesterday, eBay alleges that Craigslist’s directors — founder Craig Newmark and CEO Jim Buckmaster — held clandestine meetings last October to dilute eBay’s stake after eBay created a rival to Craigslist, called Kijiji, a Web classifieds site. (Click here fore the complaint.)
Here’s the time line of events, according to the complaint:
June 29, 2007: Ebay launched Kijiji in some U.S. markets (previously, it’d only been introduced outside the U.S.). The same day, Buckmaster sent a letter to eBay asserting that it had engaged in competitive activity.
July 12, 2007: Buckmaster sent an email to Whitman, in which he expressed “negative” feelings toward eBay’s introduction in some U.S. areas. He also said “we are no longer comfortable having eBay as a shareholder, and wish to explore options for our repurchase, or for otherwise finding a new home for these shares.”
July 23, 2007: Whitman responded, reassuring Buckmaster that eBay had taken steps to “completely firewall off” its Kijiji operations from the corporate management of its equity stake in Craigslist. She also said that eBay is “so happy” with its Craigslist relationship that “we would welcome the opportunity to acquire the remainder of (the company) we do not already own whenever you and (Mr. Newmark) feel it would be appropriate.”
October, 2007: Buckmaster and Newmark, who together own 71% of Craigslist, held two board meetings with an outside lawyer, Edward Wes, without notifying eBay. The complaint alleges that the two-person board initiated a series of transactions — such as the issuance of “reorganization” shares and the initiation of a “poison pill” — in December 2007 and January 2008 that hurt eBay’s interests as a minority shareholder, including diluting eBay’s stake in Craigslist from 28.4% to 24.85% .
On its site, Craigslist said it will file its formal response to eBay’s suit in the next few weeks. “As those who know us best will recognize, every measure we have taken has been for the sake of protecting the long term well-being of the Craigslist community.”