Friday, March 02, 2007

Monday, Aug. 25, 1986

The Great Lp Vs. Cd War

To die-hard aficionados of long-playing records, it is nothing less than a Faustian struggle between humanism and technocracy for music's soul. To the growing legion of compact-disc devotees, it is a contest that pits the past against the future of high-fidelity audio recording.

Only three years ago, the laser-read records known as compact discs, or CDs, were an untested and expensive new technology whose acceptance by consumers was the music industry's great imponderable. Today the upstart CD is challenging the decades-old supremacy of the long- playing record. Last year CDs accounted for 8.9% of the sales of the $4.4 billion recording industry, which also includes LPs and tapes. This year analysts expect CD sales of nearly 50 million discs.

But the LP is not easily relegated to obsolescence, and lately its defenders have been striking back at the shiny aluminum-and-plastic CDs. "Metallic, gritty, grainy and unnatural," declares Harry Pearson, editor and publisher of the Absolute Sound, a journal devoted to the glories of old- fashioned analog recording. Claims for the superiority of CDs, say LP partisans, are hype. "Many of the people who were initially impressed by compact discs have been disappointed," asserts Gene Rubin, a Los Angeles-area audio retailer. "There is no way that LPs are going to vanish."

The debate over compact discs goes to the heart of the new medium. In analog recording, sound waves are transcribed as grooves onto a vinyl disc. The grooves are then traced by a diamond-tipped stylus in the tone arm of the turntable to re-create the sound. In digital recording, the music is sampled by a microchip at the rate of 44,100 times a second and expressed as a series of ones and zeros. Encoded in invisible "pits," the numbers are read by a player equipped with a laser beam, which relays the information to a microcomputer that converts the digits back to sound.

Digital recordings, the critics contend, are devoid of the warmth and ambience that marks the best analog recordings when played on the finest equipment. Further, they say, the arbitrary sampling rate of a CD results in an incomplete snapshot of any given moment of sound. "The woodwinds all sound alike," claims Pearson. "You can't tell the difference between one string or the other, and you can't tell if what you're hearing is a horn or a trumpet. Digital audio is like McDonald's hamburgers. It's all alike."

That view is extreme. While CDs were disfigured in some early releases by a forced, overly brilliant presence, they have improved significantly as recording engineers have become more familiar with the different microphone placements demanded by digital recording. To be sure, claims of disc invulnerability have proved overly optimistic. And as the popularity of CDs has increased, so has the number of flawed discs, with too few pressing plants working overtime to meet demand.

Still, just as personal computers have steadily improved in speed and power, so a doubled sampling rate and better playback equipment should eliminate many of the current complaints. "The compact disc is a technology still in its infancy," says Michael Smolen, senior editor of Stereo Review magazine. "By the time it reaches adulthood, there won't be any of these specious arguments."

Analog defenders contend that there is nothing wrong with LPs that cannot be cured by a $1,000 Linn Sondek turntable, a $1,200 tone arm and an $850 rosewood cartridge, among other so-called high-end components. But it seems unlikely that the ordinary music lover will want to shell out $10,000 or more to experience the hidden delights of LPs. Despite their imperfections, CDs have overwhelming advantages. The sound is clear and bright. There is no surface noise, no turntable rumble, no pitch fluctuation. Says Leonard Feldman, who runs an audio laboratory on New York's Long Island: "I'll trade a metallic sound for the clicks, pops and hisses of LPs any day." Even though they are recorded on only one side, CDs still have more potential playing time (75 minutes) than the average LP. Cuts can be programmed to play in any order, or skipped entirely, affording music lovers the opportunity to customize their listening.

Worries about a vanishing repertory are more legitimate. The LP catalog has found a place for both the most familiar Beethoven symphonies and the most obscure baroque fugues. For now, classical and pop CDs run to the best-known artists and material. Yet some major classical labels, including RCA, CBS and the giant PolyGram complex (Deutsche Grammophon, Philips and London), have begun issuing their huge catalogs of conventionally recorded LPs as CDs.

Every advance in recording has been accompanied by the cries of those whom technology has left behind. In 1949 a British critic complained, "I ask readers if they want to feel that their collections of records are obsolete, if they really want to spend money on buying discs that will save them the trouble of getting up to change them, and if they really want to wait years for a repertory as good as what is now available to them." He was defending 78s against the encroachments of the new long-playing records in much the same terms that LP defenders cast their arguments today. And no doubt there were those who bemoaned the loss of their Edison cylinders when shellac came in.

Without gainsaying the emotional appeal of LPs, it is clear that CDs are here to stay. Good-quality players are available for $350 to $500, and the price of the discs has fallen from an average $20 to around $14. High-end enthusiasts are likely to be the last holdouts in a war that has already been lost. "CDs may not be perfect," says Feldman. "But they are the best thing to come along since Edison invented the phonograph."




Insider vs. Outsider: Reviewing 'LAT' and 'NYT' Academy Awards Coverage



By Ashley Johnson

Published: March 02, 2007 12:20 PM ET

EVANSTON, Ill. Unlike Eddie Murphy and Alan Arkin, the Los Angeles Times and The New York Times did not go quite head to head during the Oscar season, but the two newspapers did compete on the Web with revamped sites and chatty bloggers. The home team had a built-in advantage over the national champ. Still, the results overall provide insight into how top papers can best cover drawn-out cultural events over time -- and in nearly real time.

That coverage is pretty much ending, at last. Today, David Carr at The New York Times rolled the credits, as he put it, on his Carpetbagger blog.

The media has always showed up for the Oscars, but the Internet now allows newspapers to boost coverage of the event, said Tom O'Neil, longtime awards blogger and author of "Movie Awards." His Gold Derby blog was acquired by the L.A. Times in 2005 and now draws celebrities, industry executives and entertainment buffs to the Times' award season site, The Envelope.

O'Neil said he gears up for the Academy Awards six months in advance, and there's a reason for this: "What's basically happening is we're covering the Super Bowl of show business the way we cover that other Super Bowl."

But the Envelope isn't playing around. Launched in September 2005, the site offered more robust coverage this year with constant updates, feature stories and a searchable database on theenvelope.com. The Oscars section included the latest in fashion and gossip from Elizabeth Snead, Q&As with nominees, video interviews, podcasts, forums and even an Oscar pool with a $1,000 payoff.

Scott Robson, the site's executive producer, boasts that its coverage is unmatched. "We are in Los Angeles, so by that alone we're able to be a lot more comprehensive and plugged in to the day-to-day developments," he explained. "Writers can sit down with leading industry people and have conversations on a regular basis. I think nobody else is really capable of doing that -- to be able to make this into a product that is really a must-read for people in the industry."

Many of those readers are big names. O'Neil says that one producer of a Best Picture nominee told him, "I've got your column bookmarked and every morning, it's the first thing I look at." O'Neill adds: "On all fronts, I have key sources who can give us breaking news; then I'm able as a journalist to give it a perspective that no one else can."

With Hollywood in its backyard, the L.A. Times takes entertainment as seriously as The Washington Post does politics. For 11 weeks, The Envelope's online coverage – which, of course, also included the ever-expanding Golden Globes and other film awards -- was supplemented by a weekly print edition (stuffed with ads, of course) running 32-48 pages. The Oscar preview issue came out Feb. 21 and featured stories that could also be found online, such as the highs and lows of the season, semi-secret Oscar parties and how the Academy protects its brand. The strategy was to provide comprehensive coverage. Multiple bloggers and writers contributed and reporters from the L.A. Times Calendar section chipped in, too.

In contrast, for original content online, the New York Times approached the Academy Awards with one front and center voice -- David Carr.

Culture Editor Sam Sifton called Carr's Carpetbagger blog the heart of the newspaper's Oscar coverage. "His voice is unique and his reporting is intrepid. He asks a lot of questions," Sifton said about Carr, whose Monday media column in print also attracts attention for its voice and insights. "My hope is that someone will arrive at the Carpetbagger through some link or another. After tasting the entry-level drug that is the Carpetbagger, they'll then move onto the harder stuff and see that we're a pretty good newspaper, too."

Beyond Carr, The New York Time offered a revamped "Awards Season" site loaded with multimedia content, including exclusive video and images from directors, a slide show of the nominees for Best Foreign Language Film and Jake Paltrow's original black-and-white short film starring seven actors from the Great Performance issue of the Sunday Times Magazine. Unlike the L.A. Times, The New York Times didn't have a separate staff for the awards coverage, and almost every feature story online also appeared in the print edition.

Both papers declined to release traffic numbers from this year. But Stephanie Goodell from The Envelope said that traffic spikes significantly during the Oscars runup and the site had 26 million page views during its first year of operation. And The Envelope's forums stay packed with more than 3,000 registered members.

"We wanted to be able to carve out a distinct identity for it and allow it to find its own legs," Robson said. "I think that way you end up with the kind of relationship where the L.A. Times can drive traffic to The Envelope and The Envelope can drive traffic to latimes.com."

With post-Oscar coverage winding down, Sifton hasn't started thinking seriously about what The New York Times will offer online next year. But he said he hopes to have more videos and might consider adding discussion forums to help build community. Here is Carr's wrapup posting today:

David Carr.

The Big Night

Sure, the actual Academy Awards show is about the actors -- but on their Web sites, O'Neil and Carr were the key presenters last Sunday night.

Both updated their blogs about every 15 minutes, though Carr got a late start because he contributed to a larger feature story before blogging with his small laptop from the red carpet and the press room. O'Neil said he updated so frequently because the nature of blogs means someone is at home hitting "refresh" to look for a new story to pop up.

A Photoshop wiz, O'Neil set himself apart on Oscar night by posting photographs with his comments. He also showcased his 15 years of awards experience in just a few sentences. Immediately after Jennifer Hudson picked up her award, O'Neil connected her to Rita Moreno ("West Side Story") and Catherine Zeta-Jones ("Chicago") -- other "song-bursting" divas who took home Oscar gold.

O'Neil also had insight on the Best Supporting Actor award, which he referred to on his blog as the "Veteran's Achievement Award." He wrote: "It's no surprise, really, that Alan Arkin just won the award for best supporting actor over frontrunner Eddie Murphy, no, not when you think about the history of this category. ...

"What was surprising about Arkin's win was that he chose to read his relatively brief acceptance speech from a sheet of paper, making me wonder: aren't actors veterans at memorizing words? Then, when he choked up a few times while reading, it was clear why it was necessary. Only an ole pro, comfortable in his own skin, would have the wisdom to know to do that."

Over at The New York Times, Carr had another reaction: "Alan Arkin was the name they announced when it came time to open the envelope for best supporting actor, leaving Eddie Murphy with a frozen smile and Mr. Arkin with a significant bit of recognition for a lifetime of work. It was the night's first surprise, and it sent a pronounced ripple through the press room. The Bagger, btw, never saw it coming."

Carr's take highlights a major difference in their approaches: O'Neil is the more veteran voice providing historical context and Carr is the observer unfazed by the glitz and glamour of Hollywood.

"I'm much more atmospheric," Carr told E&P. "I'm much more about trying to give the reader a narrative -- what's it like to be there."

Carr's sense of excitement and business background resonated with readers who eagerly took up the Carpetbagger's challenge to generate questions for him to ask on the red carpet. On Oscar day, Carr gave a shout-out to Sasha Stone, editor of oscarwatch.com, and in the past he has linked to O'Neil, reflecting a necessary shift in the digital age. Online, the best coverage is comprehensive, even if that means tipping your hat to a writer at another paper.

"Even though we're competitors, we're not at odds," Carr said of O'Neil. "I can't avoid linking to someone like him because he has significant expertise."

In other words: Even in the same category, there's room for more than one winner.


One Woman's View: And the Award Goes to...

To the extent that the Oscar coverage was a contest, here's who won.

Best Predictions: The Envelope's Buzzmeter was eight for eight in the top categories. Carr came close but overestimated the Academy's appreciation for Eddie Murphy's performance in "Dreamgirls."

Best Moment-By-Moment Coverage: Depends where you look. The Envelope had a live play-by-play description of the action. But it was a different story on LATimes.com. Shortly after 9 PM ET NYTimes.com had acknowledged Jennifer Hudson and Alan Arkin's awards in a regularly-updated feature story, but the LATimes.com had a fashion shot of Beyoncé up. An hour or so later, LATimes.com still lagged behind with "The Award could go to" at the top of the homepage while NYTimes.com paid homage to the Queen -- Helen Mirren -- just minutes after she was named Best Actress.

Best Fashion Rewind: Both papers had large galleries, but the edge goes to NYTimes.com for a slide show that made trends easy to spot by running divas in similar dress styles and hues alongside each other.

Best Blogger Moment: The Carpetbagger for railing against the security measures that prevented him from getting back inside for more than an hour after he stepped out during the show.

Best Multimedia Offerings: A tie! The Envelope had video chats with nominees and red carpet footage. The New York Times offered slide shows and a creative -- if hard to follow -- map of who the winners thanked.


BBC News
BBC strikes Google-YouTube deal
By Tim Weber
Business editor, BBC News website

Screen shot Russell Brand on YouTube
Snack on Russell Brand's video diary
The BBC has struck a content deal with YouTube, the web's most popular video sharing website, owned by Google.

Three YouTube channels - one for news and two for entertainment - will showcase short clips of BBC content.

The BBC hopes that the deal will help it reach YouTube's monthly audience of more than 70 million users and drive extra traffic to its own website.

The corporation will also get a share of the advertising revenue generated by traffic to the new YouTube channels.

Three deals in one

The deal with Google - non-exclusive and set to run for several years - will establish three different YouTube services:

  • BBC: One of the BBC's two entertainment channels will be a "public service" proposition, featuring no advertising.

    It will show clips like trailers and short features that add value - for example, video diaries of David Tennant showing viewers around the set of Dr Who or BBC correspondent Clive Myrie explaining how difficult it is to report from the streets of Baghdad.

    The channel's main purpose is to popularise current programming and drive traffic back to the BBC's own website, and point the audience to the BBC's pages, where they can watch or download programmes in full, once the BBC Trust approves the corporation's catch-up television proposal, called iPlayer.

    screen grab of YouTube partner channel page
    The BBC's channels are on YouTube's partner pages

  • BBC Worldwide: The second entertainment channel will feature self-contained clips - about three to six minutes long - mining popular programmes in the BBC's archive. Excerpts from Top Gear, The Mighty Boosh and nature programmes presented by David Attenborough are top candidates for this channel.

    This YouTube page will carry advertising such as banner adverts, and possibly pre-roll adverts (shown as part of the video clip) as well. Controversially, the BBC Worldwide page - adverts and all - can be seen in the UK.

    BBC Worldwide insists that this is not a new departure, as BBC magazines like Top Gear and channels like BBC World and UK Living (which shows mainly BBC content) already do carry advertising.

  • BBC News: The news channel, which will be launched later this year, will show about 30 news clips per day. It will be advertising funded like a similar deal with Yahoo USA. BBC News is also offered to non-UK subscribers of Real Networks.

    Because of the advertising, these clips can be seen outside the UK only. Any UK users clicking on a link to one of the news clips on YouTube will get a message that they have no access to this clip.

Groundbreaking - and controversial

BBC YouTube screen shot
The BBC, now a "director" on YouTube

The BBC's director general, Mark Thompson, called the deal a "ground-breaking partnership" that would "engage new audiences in the UK and abroad".

The BBC's director of Future Media and Technology, Ashley Highfield, said the deal was "not about distributing content like full-length programmes; YouTube is a promotional vehicle for us".

In the United States, several television programmes experienced a discernible audience increase after they made clips available on YouTube. But the deal is likely to be controversial with other media companies, who have accused the BBC of straying from its licence-fee funded public service remit and moving too far into commercial web ventures.

Copyright protection

Several large US broadcasters, including CBS, NBC and Fox, already have similar agreements with YouTube.

YouTube makes it easy for members not only to watch and share video clips, but also to upload their own content.

However, the site is riddled with pirated film and music clips uploaded by members who do not own the copyright.

Some media firms, most prominently Viacom, have recently demanded that YouTube removes tens of thousands of clips from the site that they own the copyright for.

Mr Highfield said the BBC would not be hunting down all BBC-copyrighted clips already uploaded by YouTube members - although it would reserve the right to swap poor quality clips with the real thing, or to have content removed that infringed other people's copyright, like sport, or that had been edited or altered in a way that would damage the BBC's brand.

"We don't want to be overzealous, a lot of the material on YouTube is good promotional content for us," he said.

YouTube was founded in February 2005 and was bought by Google in November last year for $1.65bn.

In January, one of YouTube's three founders, Chad Hurley, announced that the website would soon start sharing revenue with the thousands of users who upload their own content to YouTube.


washingtonpost.com
Police: LA Puppies Dognapped in LA

In this photo released by the Los Angeles Police Department, shown are two stolen Yorkshire terriers. According to police, two armed men forced their way into a family's home and stole five dogs and four purebred Yorkshire terrier puppies, including the two shown here. The animals had been advertised for sale.

The Associated Press
Friday, March 2, 2007; 11:21 AM

LOS ANGELES -- A pair of gunmen men posing as prospective buyers of four Yorkshire puppies forced their way into a home and stole the terriers worth $2,500 each, police said.

They also fled with the family's grown terrier.

After seeing a newspaper ad, the men made an appointment to see the 8-week-old puppies on the night of Feb. 23 at Kelly Lee's home in Koreatown. When they showed up, she said, she asked them to remove their shoes before entering.

One suspect told her they would get slippers from his vehicle, Lee said. When he returned, one pointed a gun at her and three family members.

"They yelled at us to get down" on the floor of the living room, Lee said.

As one man held a gun, the other chased after the puppies scampering around the room and underneath a coffee table, home surveillance video released by police showed. He snatched one of the dogs from Lee's hands.

After stuffing the dogs one by one in a plastic garbage bag, the men fled in a silver car, police said.

No one was injured.

"It appears the suspects answered the ad, knowing the value of the puppies," police Lt. Paul Vernon said.

Although the puppies were valued at $2,500 each, the victims were most concerned about the loss of Tan-ja, the family pet for more than three years.

"I just want to find my dog, that's it," Lee said.

Newsday.com: Long Island News, Sports, Entertainment

Terriers stolen at gunpoint in Koreatown

Screen grab
Internal surveillance video shows dognappers about to enter family's home and get away with puppies valued at $2,500 each and the family Yorkie Tang-ja.

By Richard Winton
Times Staff Writer

March 2, 2007

Five Yorkshire terriers, including four puppies offered for sale, were dognapped at gunpoint from a Koreatown home, authorities said Thursday.

The home-invasion robbery was captured on video by the family's home security system.

Detectives released the tape Thursday in hopes of apprehending the two robbers, who got away with puppies valued at $2,500 each and the family's grown Yorkie, Tang-ja, said Lt. Paul Vernon of the Los Angeles Police Department.

"The family had advertised the Yorkshire terriers in a newspaper," Vernon said. "It appears the suspects answered the ad, knowing the value of the puppies."

Shortly before 10 p.m. Feb. 23, the two men came to the family's home on Manhattan Place. When a woman opened the door, one of the men pointed a handgun at her and the robbers forced their way into the home.

Vernon said that once inside, the men ordered the family to lie on the floor while one robber grabbed the dogs.

"The video shows them walking up, forcing their way into the home, forcing the family onto the floor and then chasing the dogs to round them up," Vernon said.

He said the robbers placed all five dogs in a black bag and then left in a silver car. No one was injured in the robbery, Vernon said, but the family is particularly upset about the loss of Tang-ja, who had been their pet for three years.

"This robbery is a good lesson to residents that soliciting buyers to one's home can be a risky practice," Vernon said.

Anyone with information on the robbers should contact Wilshire Division detectives Webster Wong or Ron Kim at (213) 922-8205 or call the 24-hour toll-free number at (877) LAWFULL.

Thursday, March 01, 2007

latimes.com

'Idol' helps Fox top sweeps in key demo

Thank God it's Thursday
By Martin Miller and Scott Collins
Times Staff Writers

March 2, 2007

An unexpectedly vibrant sixth-season showing of "American Idol" helped power the Fox Television network to a surprising finish in the February prime-time sweeps that ended Wednesday — first place in the highly coveted adults aged 18-to-49 demographic.

On the strength of America's most popular television program, Fox squeaked into the top spot with a 5.2 rating/13 share in the "demo," compared with a 5.0 rating/13 share for runner-up CBS, according to figures from Nielsen Media Research. The close finish was something of an upset given CBS' enormous ratings windfall from its Super Bowl broadcast earlier in the month.

ABC (3.9/10) and NBC (2.9/8) were a distant third and fourth. Sweeps periods help local stations determine what rates to charge for ad time.

"We have faith in 'American Idol,' " said Fox executive vice president and scheduling chief Preston Beckman. "We've done everything we can to protect the show and make it a once-a-year-event. We feel privileged to have it on Fox."

CBS, which tends to do better among older viewers, could still brag about finishing first in total audience. Its airing of the Super Bowl and the Grammy Awards along with its "CSI" crime franchise helped it draw an average of 15.8 million viewers during the month, easily brushing past Fox's 12.9 million. Trailing were ABC (10.3 million), NBC (8.6 million) and The CW (3.4 million).

"We had a great sweep," said Kelly Kahl, CBS programming chief. "The Super Bowl helped a lot of our series hit season highs."

The sweeps once were the sole determinant of quarterly advertising rates in television. With the spread of Nielsen's local people meters, which provide immediate ratings feedback in such major market cities as New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, sweeps are relevant mainly in medium and smaller markets.

Of the four sweeps each year, February often produces the most ambiguous snapshot of each network's true strength because it tends to be punctuated by events like the Super Bowl, the Grammys and the Oscars. And every four years, as they did in 2006, the Winter Olympics further muddy the ratings picture.

Still, every network can find something to crow about in any sweeps. ABC proclaimed victory in the 18-to-49 demo on Thursday nights thanks to the mega-hit "Grey's Anatomy." This marked the first time in 15 years that ABC won all the Thursday nights during a February sweeps. But the network has run into trouble elsewhere, and ratings for the Oscars were unspectacular, registering just a slight uptick from last year's low numbers.

For NBC, the sweeps were disappointing despite being buoyed by hits "Heroes" and "Deal or No Deal." Because it aired the Winter Olympics last year, the network was down nearly 40% in all major categories. The loss of Sunday football games because of the close of the NFL season hasn't helped.

"We're in the game. We have some encouraging signs things are coming together," said Mitch Metcalf, NBC's programming chief. "On the other hand, it's not going to be a sweep we will long remember."