Saturday, December 02, 2006

The New York Times
Printer Friendly Format Sponsored By


December 2, 2006

The Executive Producer of ‘The Daily Show’ and ‘The Colbert Report’ Is Leaving

It’s probably not an analogy Jon Stewart would appreciate, given his politics, but since soon after he began his run on Comedy Central’s “Daily Show” in 1999, Ben Karlin has served as Karl Rove to Mr. Stewart’s George W. Bush, if not his Dick Cheney.

So it has come as a shock that Mr. Karlin, an executive producer of both Mr. Stewart’s show and “The Colbert Report,” has decided to leave those jobs at the end of this month.

The sense of intrigue has only been heightened by the way word got out.

Hired by Mr. Stewart, based largely on his work at the satirical newspaper The Onion, Mr. Karlin moved from head writer of “The Daily Show” in the summer of 1999 to executive producer in 2003. While still holding that position, Mr. Karlin, 35, helped Mr. Stewart’s production company, Busboy, start “The Colbert Report,” with Stephen Colbert, for Comedy Central last fall as an executive producer, and then presided over the writing staff for Mr. Stewart’s appearance as host of the Academy Awards telecast earlier this year.

Given their close creative relationship — in recent weeks, Mr. Karlin has also been helping Mr. Stewart develop “Three Strikes,” a pilot about a minor league baseball team for Comedy Central — it came as a surprise when a comedy Web site, theapiary.org, first reported on Thursday afternoon that Mr. Karlin had decided to relinquish his roles as executive producer of both Mr. Stewart’s show and Mr. Colbert’s. Only minutes earlier, Mr. Karlin had informed the staffs of the two shows of his decision, which Comedy Central confirmed late Thursday night in a terse, two-sentence statement issued to the trade journals Variety and Broadcasting & Cable.

Why did the partnership between Mr. Stewart and Mr. Karlin begin to unravel so abruptly? The answer was not entirely clear yesterday. Comedy Central said it had learned of Mr. Karlin’s impending departure only over the last few days.

Representatives for Mr. Stewart, Mr. Colbert, Mr. Karlin and David Javerbaum — a fellow Onion alumnus who has been head writer of “The Daily Show,” and now succeeds Mr. Karlin as executive producer — said yesterday that neither they nor their clients would have any comment on the matter.

The only principal who would come to the phone was Doug Herzog, the president of Comedy Central. In a telephone interview yesterday, he said Mr. Karlin’s main motivation appeared to be a desire to pull back from the grueling pace that he has kept up for more than seven years. Mr. Karlin routinely shuttled the two blocks between Mr. Stewart’s studio in Midtown Manhattan and Mr. Colbert’s, sometimes traveling by scooter as one show ended its taping and the other began.

“Ben has been doing this a long time,” Mr. Herzog said. “It’s a grind. Four nights a week. Forty-some odd weeks a year.”

Mr. Herzog added: “I couldn’t stress more that it’s all amicable.”

An executive involved in the shows who agreed to be interviewed only on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak, said Mr. Karlin’s “Daily Show” contract had been up and had not been renewed, though yesterday it was not at all clear why. The same executive said Mr. Javerbaum, who joined “The Daily Show” in 1999, had made known in recent months that he wished to leave “The Daily Show,” but with Mr. Karlin’s departure, he has now been persuaded to stay.

Mr. Karlin, who had relinquished day-to-day management of “Colbert” to other producers in recent months, has not been replaced as an executive producer at “Colbert.” He will continue to be associated with both “The Daily Show” and “Colbert” as a consultant.

An orderly transition is critical to Comedy Central, given how important both shows are to that cable channel. On Monday through Thursday nights, when the shows are broadcast, Mr. Stewart’s show draws an average audience of about 1.6 million viewers, and Mr. Colbert’s 1.2 million, both up substantially from a year ago, according to figures from Nielsen Media Research provided by Comedy Central.

Of no small comfort to Comedy Central is that Mr. Stewart and Mr. Colbert are actively involved in the writing and producing of their respective shows.


Journalism School Probes Possible Cheating on Ethics Exam

Talk Is Tense at Columbia, but Some See Incident as Real-Life Lesson

http://www.insure.com/images/award-columbialogo.gif

By Robin Shulman
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, December 3, 2006; A11

NEW YORK -- It was an ethics exam in a journalism class, and someone may have cheated.

Ironic? Yes. Unfortunate? Certainly. But what made the incident particularly notable was where and when it took place: at Columbia University, one of the premier journalism schools in the country, at a time when media ethics are much in question.

On Friday, Columbia's Graduate School of Journalism convened a meeting to discuss misconduct in the final exam for the required ethics course "Critical Issues in Journalism."

But the school was so wary of making specific accusations that, afterward, it was not even clear what misconduct had taken place.

Students had been given a 48-hour period to sign onto a Columbia Web site to take the final exam. They then had 90 minutes to answer two essay questions.

But at least one student reported cheating to the school's administrators -- without giving any names, said students who attended the meeting.

RadarOnline.com first reported about the investigation on Thursday, and the New York Times ran a story Friday. The Romenesko blog, which focuses on stories about the news media, linked to both Friday morning.

That afternoon, when the journalism school's deans convened the tense meeting, mandatory for all those enrolled in the course, about a dozen upset students lined up at a microphone to ask why deans were not doing more to apprehend the culprit, and to plead with other students to turn in the cheater in their midst, said students who attended.

After the meeting, students milled outside the school, discussing the problem with a level of anxiety that seemed to say more about the precarious state of journalism -- in an era of Jayson Blair-style fabrications and shrinking newspaper jobs -- than about one or several graduate students cheating on a test.

"It's going to affect us for years to come," said Jack Gillum, 23. "Columbia's going to have this badge of dishonor."

"If people did cheat, it makes me really angry," he added, noting that he pays much of his $43,422 yearly tuition and fees by himself and does not want his degree to be devalued.

"There's kind of a palpable fear: What's going to happen when you go for a job interview?" said Caroline Preston, 26.

But other students said the investigation has provided them with the best practical education they could have wanted.

"In the past week I've learned more about ethics than in the past semester," said Kate Grace, 26, as she ticked off recent lessons in anonymous sourcing, rumor and hype.

Peter O'Dowd, 25, said he learned what it is like when the tables are turned and the journalist becomes the news: what it is like to be interviewed, deal with leaks and avoid talking to reporters.

The teacher of the ethics class, Samuel Freedman, declined to comment for this article. And a reporter seeking to talk to several deans, themselves journalists, was referred instead to Barbara Fasciani, the school's director of communications and special events.

"What has happened is there's been some difficulty with the way the exam has been administered," said Fasciani. Confidentiality issues prevent her from saying more, she said. "There was some kind of snag with the timing, how it was sent out and how students were taking it," she said.

Asked if the school was investigating whether one student cheated by offering exam questions to another, she said: "It may be."

In any event, an extra take-home question has been devised to adjust for any unfairness in the exam. The new essay topic, like the school's real-life conundrum, involves a report of cheating by an unnamed individual, followed by rumors and uncertainty.

"You are the executive editor of a newspaper," begins Exam Essay Question III, forwarded to a reporter by a student. "You receive a tip from a credible source that one or more unspecified articles in recent editions of the newspaper contain fabricated material. No more details are given." No one admits responsibility. What do you do?

MSN Tracking Image
MSNBC.com

Man sentenced to 7 years for movie piracy
Johnny Ray Gasca sneaked a camcorder into movie screenings
http://www.uncrate.com/men/images/sony-DCR-DVD403-camcorder.jpg
The Associated Press
Updated: 5:06 p.m. PT Dec 1, 2006

LOS ANGELES - A man convicted of sneaking camcorders into movie screenings and selling the pirated tapes in video stores was sentenced Friday to seven years in federal prison.

Johnny Ray Gasca was the first person charged in a federal crackdown on video piracy.

Prosecutors showed the jury Gasca’s diary in which he wrote that he earned up to $4,000 a week by attending the screenings. Prosecutors alleged he sold the films through small video stores or on the street.

Gasca represented himself during a weeklong trial, saying he did not intend to profit from his actions. He said evidence was embellished to make him appear to be a “prince of piracy.”

Gasca was arrested in Burbank and charged with misdemeanor burglary after sneaking a camcorder into a screening of “The Core” in September 2002.

The next month, security officers at a Los Angeles theater found him with a camcorder at a screening of the Eminem movie “8 Mile.”

And in January 2003, a theater camera meant to record audience reaction at an “Anger Management” screening caught Gasca in the front row with his camcorder trained on the screen.

He was convicted in June 2005 of three counts of copyright infringement. Gasca was also convicted of an escape charge for fleeing his attorney’s custody while awaiting trial and of using a fake Social Security number.


Video Visionaries Meld Traditional TV and the Web

The image “http://www.nawcc.org/school/images/tv.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

By Mike Musgrove
Washington Post Staff Writer
Saturday, December 2, 2006; D01

Is TV moving onto the Internet or is the Internet moving onto TV? As the lines between the two begin to blur, it's getting harder to tell.

Fans of Comedy Central's "South Park," for example, can still watch the latest episode by tuning in on Wednesday nights. But they can also turn to Comedy Central's Web site to watch an ad-sponsored episode. If they're willing to cough up a couple of dollars, they can even download the shows for viewing through an Xbox or an iPod.

At iVillage, a Web site that caters to women, the push is toward the TV set. On Monday, the site, which was acquired by NBC Universal this year, is launching a daytime TV show called "iVillage Live," which will be broadcast on some NBC stations, the Bravo network and the Web.

It's a nontraditional approach to broadcast television that's been growing in popularity in recent months: broadcasting shows on both the Internet and traditional TV to give advertisers as many viewers as possible. At the same time, the blurred line between traditional and online video is accommodating a growing variety of viewers: those who prefer to watch on a TV, those who gravitate more toward the Web and even those who like to watch on their mobile phones or TiVo recorders.

Thanks to popular sites like YouTube and Google Video, video content has become one of the most popular offerings on the Internet. That's led to a flood of amateur sites that look more like cable TV services, complete with "channels" -- clickable icons on a Web page that bring up a lineup of shows to watch -- that accommodate different interests.

"This is definitely the Wild West in some ways," said Adam Berrey, vice president of marketing and strategy at Brightcove, an online video company. "It's in the very early stages, and people are still learning."

So far, Brightcove customers have built online video programming networks dedicated to topics as varied as pet care and Miami night life. The channels are available only on computers, but Berrey hopes to soon offer viewers a way to watch on their TV sets.

One way Brightcove is trying to get on TV screens is to work with products connected to TV sets, such as the TiVo digital video recorder. Together, Brightcove and TiVo are creating a video portal that allows TiVo subscribers to upload homemade video clips and create unique channels -- a lineup of shows from various sources on TiVo's Now Playing list -- that friends and family members can watch through their own TiVo boxes.

"It's the democratization of video content," Berrey said. "People are going to get away from Channel 9 or Channel 10."

Heavy.com, which shows racy programming targeted at college-age men, has teamed with Verizon Wireless and Sprint Nextel to offer video clips for the mobile-phone crowd. It has also partnered with TiVo to get its clips on TV sets.

The movement also helps TiVo broaden its reach beyond a DVR that stores traditional television shows. By offering amateur video channels alongside shows that come in from a Heavy.com or a Cnet, as well as those recorded from ABC or HBO, the company offers a viewing experience that "otherwise wouldn't be able to exist due to the economics of television," said Tara Maitra, general manager of programming for TiVo.

Ultimately, the broader presence of programming on multiple formats could help traditional shows.

When CBS launched its channel on YouTube just over a month ago, the 300 video clips from its shows featured on the site got nearly 30 million views. Since then, ratings for the network have gone up, and viewership of "The Late Show with David Letterman," which got the biggest boost, was up by 200,000 over the past month.

"We're getting people who don't watch the show routinely to say, 'I'd forgotten how funny Dave is, I've got to go check him out again,' " said Dana McClintock, vice president of communications at CBS. "It's about exposing your content to new audiences -- and, of course, thereby making more money from it."

But putting TV shows on the Internet is only one part of the equation -- the easier part. Getting shows downloaded or streamed over the Internet to play on living-room sets has been more difficult.

Apple Computer is expected to announce a device early next year that will plug into a television set and pull in video from computers via home networks. Josh Bernoff, a technology analyst with Forrester Research, said he expected to see at least four new products that perform similar tricks at next month's Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas.

"Now that there's all this video content on the Web, everyone is trying to figure out if there's any way to get it onto the television," he said.

These first attempts at melding TV and Internet video are a little lackluster; put a grainy video clip from YouTube on a television screen and it doesn't necessarily make for must-see TV, Bernoff said. And, while some TiVo owners may enjoy the TivoCast offering, so far the six-month-old service hasn't been compelling enough to sell new TiVo units for the company, he said.

"For any of these things to get interesting, you have to have access to a large catalogue of content," Bernoff said. "This is going to happen, but it will be quite a while before any of these collections are more than a curiosity."

Already, companies that offer niche programming -- such as National Geographic and Discovery -- are talking to companies such as Brightcove to explore the advertising network that could become available through new technologies. The business models are still being fine-tuned, but ad revenues are growing for online video content, Berrey said.

"This is not just another way to watch 'South Park,' " he said, "It's a way to watch a whole bunch of stuff you were never able to watch before."

Friday, December 01, 2006

Aging rockers set to lose rights on early hits

The image “http://www.hecklerspray.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/10/Beatles.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

By Mike Collett-WhiteFri Dec 1, 9:34 AM ET

When finance minister Gordon Brown stands up to make his pre-budget speech next week, aging rockers Cliff Richard, The Beatles and The Rolling Stones might do well to tune in.

Not normally the stuff of rock'n'roll, Wednesday's address looks set to reject music industry calls for an extension of copyright on sound recordings to 95 years from 50, meaning veteran acts' early hits could soon be free for all to use.

The government commissioned Andrew Gowers to review all areas of intellectual property law, including challenges thrown up by the consumption of music and film over the Internet, and he is seen as unlikely to recommend a copyright extension.

His conclusions are expected to be published next week as part of the chancellor's annual pre-budget report.

Official sources say the Labour government appears more swayed by the right of consumers to access music cheaply, or, if it is 50 years old, essentially for free, than by old performers seeking protection.

Commentators also point out that the 50-year sound recording cover is standard in most European countries, and Britain would be unlikely to want to stand alone by extending it.

Richard has led the way in highlighting the issue, with his first hit "Move It!," from 1958, perilously close to the cut off point for copyright protection.

More significantly for record labels who do a lucrative trade in remastering and repackaging old hits, The Beatles catalog could be up for grabs from 2012 and 2013, including early hits like "Love Me Do" and "I Want To Hold Your Hand."

Then come The Shadows and The Rolling Stones, to name but a few.

In 2005, Elvis Presley's record label re-released his British No. 1 hits over consecutive weeks to cash in ahead of the deadline.

MUSIC "STOPS BEING YOURS"

David Arnold, who composed the scores for four James Bond movies, argues that the 50-year copyright limit discriminates against performers and record companies.

"I don't think anyone involved in music's creation can understand how, after a certain amount of time, it stops being yours and starts being everyone else's," he told Reuters.

"We need to do the groundwork so there is an element of protection for artists and record companies who take a risk with an artist," he added. "That's if we value the entertainment industry and value music in our society."

Richard has said he would like to see copyright protection for singers and record labels extended, pointing out that songwriters enjoy protection for their lifetime plus 70 years.

In the United States, copyright protection is 95 years.

Industry bodies like the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) argue that the failure to extend protection on old hits will jeopardise investment in future talent.

Emma Pike, chief executive of the British Music Rights group, sides with the BPI, but says the Gowers Review raises broader issues for music and film in the 21st century.

"Sales of legitimate music downloads are growing exponentially ... but the overall picture globally is still one of decline," she said.

"There is a statistic that 80 percent (of Internet music download traffic) is illegal and 20 percent legal, so we have an enormous amount of work to do and the music industry simply can't do it on its own."